Civility

My response just now to someone in the Degrowth group who commented to the effect that we all have the right to speak sarcastically and rudely to people, in the name of having a productive sharing of ideas:

I understand the definition of “civil” as in civic. In this context here on this thread, I am using another common definition of civil, as in being basic polite and not rude to people.

I understand how the circumstances in the world can induce bitterness and sarcasm in any of us. But it’s best to not use it on each other. Not only for the reason of basic human decency, but also for the very pragmatic reason that it stifles the sharing of ideas. If people think they’re going to get their heads bitten off, fewer and fewer people are willing to share a thought.

I have witnessed this pattern in more groups than I can count, as I have co-adminned many groups and simply been a very active participant in many more.

When I start to write a comment to an internet stranger and realize my comment sounds harsh, I try to pretend I’m talking to a friend or sister. And I edit accordingly.

I strive to convey the same substance, but with the tone and wording that I would use on somebody I know and love. It takes a little extra effort but it seems to be working well so far.

Degrowth is not a cult. But we are a grassroots movement, a kind of in-group, and people need to be able to have civilized discussions with one another. If we can’t even talk with each other, there’s not much hope for us to communicate with “civilians.”

•It’s possible to express anger politely. It’s possible to express despair without taking it out on others.
•It’s possible to express intellectual disagreement without being rude or condescending.
•Same with expressing skepticism.

We are dealing with a lot of deep-seated emotions in this movement and in related movements. Our challenge is to avoid taking it out on each other as we move forward.

Super simple community hydration station

Self-explanatory emergency water-station in my front yard. People can keep the cups, or toss em in the basket to be washed and reused.

Beloved Coleman jug courtesy of my parents and the 1960s. Vintage stuff ftw!!!

At first I was thinking of this as an example of the second ethic of Permaculture design, care of people and all other living things. But then I realized that it has ALL THREE of the Permaculture ethics.

•Care of the earth: using durable everyday items that are still good, and refraining from purchasing new unnecessarily. (The plastic cups were on their way to landfill; a friend who gets boba tea every day gave them to me and I have tried to find a use for them.)

•Care of people and all other living things: trying to help do my part to make sure people stay hydrated, and also, any water that splashes onto the ground is helping other species.

•Limit consumption and share surplus: I’m sharing a resource that I have extra and can spare. And I am voluntarily self-limiting my consumption by not purchasing a separate thermos jug just for me. Instead, sharing my same old one with the community. Another surplus resource I’m sharing is time. Since I work mainly at home and in my immediate neighborhood, I have the luxury of time to be able to monitor this water station.

In addition to being a good example of all three ethics … This water station also embodies the permaculture design principle of “stacking functions.” One of my favorite of the 12 permaculture design principles. Everything in my yard not only serves its direct purpose, but also additionally serves as a demonstration site for my permaculture design & education services. I sometimes refer to my yard as my 3-D business card or design showroom.

Another function I’m stacking here is emotional/mental wellbeing. By being surrounded with many beloved everyday objects from our childhood that I find beautiful, I get a lot of joy and comfort. Also in the realm of emotional well-being, the various little micro-amenities in my yard help me keep an eye on the emotional and mental health of my neighborhood and community.

Notice how I get personal benefits and they don’t take away from any of the community benefits. And vice versa, the fact that there are multiple community benefits doesn’t take away from my personal benefits.

As I mention in the videos that I recently posted on my TikTok and YouTube channels, this is one of many low-stakes experiments in my front yard. What I call “porous property.” It includes things like the corner benches, and the little beach-toy lending library. Helping to raise the level of trust and compassion in our society, where it often seems like people’s willingness to trust is on the wane nowadays.

Doing things like this takes a little bit of leap of faith. You have to trust that most people won’t vandalize or steal. And also, you have to be willing to face the possibility that that is what might happen. But if we start with low stakes like this, it’s not as risky.

Wow, it’s amazing how much ended up coming out of just a little water-station. What we do makes a bigger difference than we think. Feel free to share your examples! And thank you so much for following my page.

You can see pictures of my super simple community hydration station setup right here. On my DEEP GREEN Facebook page.

#porousproperty #hydrationstation #peoplehelpingpeople #heatemergency #socialpermaculture #thistooispermaculture #peoplecareethic #water

Rejoinders for pesky bicycle questions

Warning! Extra salty post ahead.

Starting a file of answers for questions with unwinnable answers. In no particular order.

This question was prompted by constantly being asked by so-called environmentalist, so-called liberals constantly asking me how did you get here, did you ride your bicycle here, etc.

And I was constantly answering them with an irritating diatribe that usually included the idea that “if you — being the people with the clout and the wallets — had been pushing for public transportation and walkable neighborhoods all along instead of moving out to the rich, fake-environmentalist suburbs, you would not be treating nonmotorists as some kind of novelty. Which is really fucking offensive by the way.”

And you need to stop NIMBYing out the apartments and townhouses as soon as possible, because you are going to be needing those people to clean your giant houses and wipe your asses in the next few years if you keep insisting on living out there in the Home Creepo zone.

Anyway! Fellow activists, anarchists, middle-class dropouts, and other associated misfits: Some all-purpose answers for you in case you need them in your own exchanges with the perennially irritating “liberal environmentalist” tribe.

PS. Extra demerits for you if your housing development has “plantation” or “preserve” in the name.

Why do you want to know?

There’s no answer I can give to that question without making things worse.

I’m not here to be your sideshow freak or zoo animal. Satisfy your curiosity elsewhere.

I give out that information on a need to know basis.

I have stopped answering that question because people keep getting the wrong idea.

Stop it. I’ve already talked to you about this.

Mu.

MU!!! Which part of “mu” did you not understand?

You’re asking the wrong question. The question you should be asking is…

No. I do not need a ride. With you. Ever.

Further Exploration:

“The Japanese word Mu,” by Robert Pirsig. “Mu becomes appropriate when the context of the question becomes too small for the truth of the answer. When the Zen monk was asked whether a dog had Buddha nature he said “Mu,” meaning that if he answered either way he was answering incorrectly.”

Graciously declining invitations to participate in faraway events

Over the past couple of years I have been refining my wording in order to be able to get my point across better. Here is one example. A person across the state has persistently invited me to an event that I love the sound of but do not want to physically travel to. (I have helped them boost their social-media posts as I often do with like-minded people and events.)

I stacked functions by making the response public — responding in a comment to the post instead of responding privately by DM — and tagging other public permaculture people.

Here is what I said:

That’s really nice of you to think of me as an artist that you would want to invite to your event. And extra sweet of you to offer overnight hospitality to a person who does not have a car and would be arriving by public transport.

But that would be a very long and energy-expensive trip for me. (Talking about human energy here, not just fossil energy.)

And, I stay busy with art events & other events in my local area. And also I need to save my carbon/eco-footprint budget for the long train trip to see my family.

However, I will be happy to keep my ears open for local artists for you. If I hear of anyone in your part of the state who is looking to participate in art events I will tell them about your event. And I bet <fellow permie teacher activist person> and <other fellow permie teacher activist person> know lots of potential people as well. Also possibly <yet another FPTAP> would know some artists if he is still living in the area.

And, although I believe both <yet another FPTAP> and <yet another FPTAP> have moved away from the area, I imagine they may still know some people who are artists and /or connected with the art community. Who would probably be very interested!

Woodstock Boomers Revival Manifesto

Or how we can get our groove back. This is a work in progress. Just posting here because I am decluttering my Notes app. And also because things can be useful even in rough draft mode. (Note, if anything sounds totally weird or nonsensical it’s because I missed something while proofreading my talk-to-text.)

Woodstock boomers revival manifesto

This is for all my fellow what I would call Earth Day boomers or Woodstock boomers, who are genuinely horrified and distraught at the state of the planet and the effect it is having on people and all other living things.

This might be a manifesto, might be a kind of Ted talk, we will see what it turns into.

We spoke up against the war in Vietnam. We Spoke up about environmental crisis.

Then, fast forward to the 80s, somehow we became tame and venal. Caught up in affluence and prosperity. Some of us didn’t last for long and dropped out. But no judgment on those who didn’t drop out; we all get caught up in things sometimes. And some people had kids into the equation and that weighed in favor of them taking the corporate route.

But, now it is now.

I see a lot of my fellow boomers crying out against climate change, pollution, but then not being willing to do the things that will actually help unravel the structure.

In no particular order.

First and foremost that came to my mind, we need to acknowledge that the way we went about our war protests was wrong. Spitting on veterans and calling soldiers baby killers was wrong. Our focus needed to be on the government that was doing the wrong, not on the people who were conscripted and not able to take the college loophole.

Or, not on the people who felt like they were doing the right thing by signing up because they didn’t want to just leave it to someone else.

So we need to make some kind of amends to veterans. Saying thank you for your service is problematic in a lot of ways, as others have already pointed out. What we could do is join Veterans for Peace; donate to organizations that provide mental health care for veteran; and other services. And, we can also refrain from persuading our young people to join the military. We never wanted to live in a world where the best chance that a kid has for a stable life is to sign a contract where he promises to kill on the orders of the government. That is no deal. And we need to stop being all happy when our nieces and nephews and grandkids etc. I thinking of that as a path. We need to support them in their hearts path.

I also want to talk about the smug memes that we are posting. Oh look at the simple life we lead, look at the dangerous stunts we did on the bicycle. And yet now we won’t even let go of our fourth house, or take our 401(k) off of Wall Street. And order the others they simply have something like a basic life.

Some steps we can do.

We can stop the consumerist travel. Yes we can just stop. Most of the fun we’re having is on social media, not in the reality. We are old as dirt and we need to start just being happy at home like our sensible grandparents did.

We can stand up to our husbands about the lawns for god sake. Seriously? We’re going to tell our grandkids that we let the planet die because our HOA wouldn’t let us have a wildflower yard. Or our husband liked to mow? What the hell is wrong with us. Tell the man to stay the hell out of the wildflowers.

We don’t get to have it both ways. We don’t get to think of ourselves as some kind of cool revolutionary, and not be doing any of the work right now.

We can stop being members of so-called “liberal” congregations who ridicule people who actually walk the walk.

another big thing, we need to stop making ourselves wrong and saying that we were being unrealistic and impractical and idealistic back in the 60s and 70s. We were not wrong. The way that we went about a lot of our stuff was erroneous in various ways, but we were not fundamentally wrong and we need to stop making fun of hippies and saying that we were impractical and then finally we grew up and now we’re being practical. Because we are not being practical, we are being basically murderous with our habits.

Yes, we got caught up in drugs, and some of that involved sexual exploitation. but there have always been hot hippie boys that made a mini harem or cult around themselves. We needed to deconstruct the patriarchy and we did not, now we can.

We should not throw the baby out with the bathwater as it says.

I used to wonder why my dad was so contemptuous of hippies. Toward the end of his life he told me that we never should’ve been in Vietnam. That was not what I expected to hear from a 22-year career Navy officer, but I found out after he passed that he and many of his classmates that Annapolis has opposed the war. So if you feel a certain way but you/squash your heart’s voice, what are you going to do but be contemptuous of people who are acting on their heart?

We can stop living in car dependent cities and suburbs. We need to move where we can walk to our needs. Or else we need to invite people to live with us. We cannot keep being these entitled elders who expect everyone to wait on us hand and foot.

And we need to stop NIMBYing apartment complexes and town houses out of the neighborhoods. Hey who knows, a lot of these people might end up being our home health care or yard care.

And we need to stop pretending that our fancy electric cars are going to save the world. That is bullshit.

Not facing the truth makes a person cranky. I know, I’ve done it. Done it both ways.

We can protect our grandkids from getting into college debt. Encourage them to pursue a trade, pursue their heart. The so-called practical path is not practical it has made us into a murderous society.

Further exploration:

“Decades after Kent State shooting, the tragic legacy shapes its activism” (Jonathan Edwards; Washington Post). “The university where 13 student protesters were killed or injured during the Vietnam War era worries that other schools have learned nothing from its history.”

“How to support student protests; the history of Cinco de Mayo; environmental hazards in Gaza; and the racist history of the filibuster.” (Nicole Cardoza and guest writers; Anti-Racism Daily 5/5 weekend edition). “Over 2,000 students and faculty have been arrested as student-led protests grow at college campuses across the U.S. Many of these demonstrations are being misinterpreted as generic acts of solidarity with communities in Gaza. But, in reality, students have clear and comprehensive demands from their universities – and they’re not budging. Although each school has it’s own focus, here’s what’s common throughout their demands. …”

Earth Day 2019 playlist

Came across this in my Notes app while I was doing some e-decluttering. A lot of the stuff is still things I would recommend, even though obviously I’ve seen & recommended a video or two since 2019! This playlist is some thing I set up for the earth day event that I organized in 2019 at Cinematique theater on Beach Street, downtown Daytona Beach.

Earth Day Playlist 2019

• Backyard Native Plant Pocket Prairie https://youtu.be/JbCb5ZlxHoE

• Cherise – Doula music video

• Ocean-Friendly Gardens CPR 1:29 https://youtu.be/UB3tUmO8PFQ

• Urban Wetlands Make Cities Liveable 1:55 https://youtu.be/v3GXlESxaR4

• Ocean-Friendly Garden Tour 3:40 https://youtu.be/GO4Zmm05FRs

• The Living Machine 2:40 https://youtu.be/fmdsBlWwSTU

• Rain Gardens: Stormwater Pollution Solutions 5:47 https://youtu.be/Bv0O2UcP2_s

• Urban Forests: How Do Trees Benefit a City? 4:20 https://youtu.be/A6miJ6YEOdI

• Placemaking in Detroit 2:55 https://youtu.be/1zi8rCiDrl4

• The Story of Bottled Water 8:05 https://youtu.be/Se12y9hSOM0

• The Story of Stuff – intro https://youtu.be/OqZMTY4V7Ts

• China’s Green Roof Revolution https://youtu.be/N8L1hDWACKQ

• Scythe vs Mower https://youtu.be/1I4RNenmfFI

• DIY Outdoor Solar Shower 3:52 https://youtu.be/2JW87R0WxP8

• Village Homes – City of the Future – Mollison 10:37 https://youtu.be/QmFVxPjG2JI

• Meet the Rainwater Harvesting Champions of Ethiopia, Kenya, and Uganda (RAIN Foundation, 9:54) https://youtu.be/xJLTuJZ2vL8

• Rainwater Harvesting on Open Oceans (Kevin Chiang, 13:38) https://youtu.be/rMfeQJMSRzY

• Overview of Lancaster-Homestead Water-Harvesting Strategies (Brad Lancaster home, 12:12) https://youtu.be/xdvmJ-AFlRA

• Planting the Rain To Grow Abundance (Brad Lancaster TEDx 17:53) https://youtu.be/I2xDZlpInik

• A “Laundry to Landscape” Greywater System (Greywater Action 1:50) https://youtu.be/WdV_gbOipQs

• Mulch Basins Catch a Stormwater Rain Bomb (Oasis Designs 4:03) https://youtu.be/6ylVDvfm1G4

• Composting in an Apartment 5:08 https://youtu.be/E5kGAxHsesY

• This Monster Plant Is Trying To Take Over – What If We Let It? https://youtu.be/_1Qj4Bm47hA

• Beyond the War on Invasive Species: Quick Review https://youtu.be/8-QDC6RxzfU

• Theaster Gates: How To Revive a Neighborhood (with beauty, creativity, and…) https://youtu.be/S9ry1M7JlyE

• Artist Theaster Gates Turns Chicago’s Open Spaces into Incubators for Culture https://youtu.be/j3izd9U9xm4

• Dr Vandana Shiva: Solutions to the Food and Ecological Crisis Facing Us (TEDx Masala 11:40) https://youtu.be/_eLi_PJKUoo

• Composting Toilet Creates “Humanure” (Austin American Statesman 2:56) https://youtu.be/F9JgpVbDbHM

• Poop in a Bucket Frank Meyer 2:53 https://youtu.be/t_pFAMSv6pM

• Eco-Friendly Wastewater Treatment System 2:46 https://youtu.be/pXaXjzbccPo

• You Will Never Throw Away Grass Clippings After Watching This (GoGreen 3:56) https://youtu.be/PSAZu1yiJ34

• China’s Greening of Vast Kubuqi Desert https://youtu.be/kp4PikdJhKM

• Greening the Desert – Geoff Lawton 5:21 https://youtu.be/sohI6vnWZmk

• Greening the Desert – 10 yr timeline 3:54 https://youtu.be/W69kRsC_CgQ

• Can the “Great Green Wall” Stop Desertification in China 9:37 https://youtu.be/pSn6S-H7m-8

• Make Basket from Palm Leaf — Cambodia https://youtu.be/VP-zd6T8CLM

• Palmetto Basket Class – Making a Basket from 1 Leaf Lafayette LA https://youtu.be/ErgbcOhVgT0

• Make Bioplastic by Yourself! Science Luxembourg 1:03 https://youtu.be/Cqg-QpaF1lk

• “Edible Glass” made from Seaweed https://youtu.be/nva6MGqArFU

• Whole Foods, Gentrification, and the Erasure of Black Harlem https://youtu.be/onU2p0fU_J4

• Urban Permaculture Oasis at St. Pete Ecovillage 8:21 https://youtu.be/-OPkuGozcl8

• Can Locals and Transplants See Eye To Eye on Gentrification 11:41 https://youtu.be/UIGXgWifPyI

• Michael Pawlyn: Using Nature’s Genius in Architecture https://youtu.be/3QZp6smeSQA

• What Is Fleet Farming 2:21 https://youtu.be/RWucD9jslkM

• Fleet Farming Inspiring Future Urban Farmers 4:09 https://youtu.be/MxN6xXpinVI

• Passive Cooling Your Home 2:14 https://youtu.be/-pO4w1Qt6pE

• Less Walls, More Life — Design in the Tropics TEDx 11:46 https://youtu.be/Heb9l59L6ZU

• Can Tiny Houses Save Detroit 5:53 https://youtu.be/qY4s5T6cLSw

• Can Urban Farming Spur Job Growth and Better Health https://youtu.be/oEauo21ELD4

• Floating Farms of Bangladesh BBC News https://youtu.be/CONfhrASy44

• How To Make a Floating Island 3:03 https://youtu.be/-LQqjKLwG7I

• Woody Tasch: Slow Money 4:32 https://youtu.be/WJuUcaVtifg

• How the Urban Community Can Stop Gentrification and Restore 2:52 https://youtu.be/H-XI3-loRys

• What We Don’t Understand About Gentrification Stacey Sutton 13:53 https://youtu.be/XqogaDX48nI

• Superblocks: How Barcelona Is Taking City Streets Back from Cars 5:31 https://youtu.be/ZORzsubQA_M

• How Highways Wrecked American Cities – highway removal projects 4:39 https://youtu.be/odF4GSX1y3c

• Carfree Cities: The Gritty Details 5:47 https://youtu.be/j9qUvTTlF2Y

-30-

end marker

So there!

Beach-toy plastic musings

Had a beautiful walk to the beach for a dip just now. Around 7 PM. The sun is setting these days around 8 so it was a nice time to go.

When I got out of the water and walked up the sand, passing by the trash cans as I headed up toward the road, I noticed a bunch of new-looking beach toys had been stuffed in the trash. The people who had put them there said there was nothing wrong with the toys; it was just that the family was getting ready to fly home.

One small motel on the A1A up towards Ormond has a toybox where the tourists can leave their toys for the next people. It would be cool if some of the big hotels were to do that too.

Well, I gathered up the toys and brought them home and added them to my beach toy library.

I was glad that I had happened to be there to rescue them, but it was kind of sad too. All of this plastic. And so much prosperity, so much income disparity, that buying things and throwing them away is some thing that people don’t think twice about anymore.

Suddenly a forgotten memory popped into my mind’s eye. The inflatable rafts that we had had growing up. They were navy-blue on one side, red on the other, and made of canvas. I am pretty sure they lasted us through 8 or 10 summers. I can remember having them when I was seven, and I think I can remember them still being with us when I went off to college.

Somehow the memory had a deep quality. Like, it might sound corny, but we had an actual relationship with those rafts. The rafts went with us through several moves, rode the waves of Pacific and Atlantic and floated in some lakes and maybe even a pool or two. I’m pretty sure we have at least a photo or two around still, of us kids with those rafts. I can feel the texture of the wet canvas on my skin.

Now, lest this should sound like some sort of bombastic boomer bragging — it’s not. I’m not putting down people for having plastic beach toys. And not saying I will look how great we are for having these artisanal authentic canvas inflatable rafts. What I’m saying is that people deserve better, the same as we had better, way back then. At a much less affluent time of our society, to boot.

On a related note … Yesterday I got an email newsletter from the apparel company Patagonia, which is known for its eco-responsible policies regarding well-made clothing, and repairing and recycling clothing. And even discouraging people from buying more than they need.

The Patagonia newsletter had a link to a film that has been made by Patagonia. The title: The Shit-throp-o-cene: Welcome to the age of cheap crap. It was pretty funny, if a little too painstakingly clever at times, and it made some really good points. You can watch it for free.

It struck me that my little beach-toy lending library is a way of somehow elevating and redeeming what would otherwise be trash plastic. I’ve turned the little buckets and scoops and shovels and boogie board and plastic inflatable life-rings into a bit of cheerful bright-colored art hanging on my fence. Usable art, that anyone can borrow and enjoy — and, I hope, make a sweet and lasting memory.